Best Fixed Blade Broadheads

Sometimes the simplest solution is the best solution. If you hunt with a bow, you can’t take any chances when sighting and loosing an arrow at your target. There’s so much that goes into this dying sport and, when you take the shot, you need to make contact.

Even then, most hunts don’t end there. You can spend a lot of time tracking your prey after you’ve hit it, waiting for it to succumb to its injuries.

For a successful bow hunt, you need good arrows. There’s a lot of arrow types out there, each with their own advantages.

The more complicated the arrow, the higher the risk. Mechanical broadheads rely on complicated pressure-based systems, so sometimes the blade won’t emerge properly.

If that happens, you can miss or bounce straight off your prey, and they’ll flee into the brush. With prey getting smarter each hunting season, you might not see another opportunity to strike for weeks, even months. 

The answer is simple. If you want reliability and clout behind every shot you take, you’re going to want fixed blade broadheads.

There’s no trickery here, no spring mechanisms, so the blade is there from the start. You can feel it with your own fingers and, if you get good ones, they’ll have multiple serrated points to do maximum damage to your target.

Combined with the weight of the sharp hunks of metal at each arrow’s tip, and you have a battering ram that will pierce flesh and shatter bone.

Do you want fixed blade broadheads? We’re giving you four. Find a review for each one below, pick the one you like, and go get it. It’s that simple.

1. G5 Outdoors Montec Broadheads

When you’re looking for a quick fix to your problems, it’s great to find a brand you know and respect.

That’s why our first recommendation for your fixed blade broadheads is from G5 Outdoors. Their simple yet notorious Montec broadheads are what most of us think of when we think of fixed blade broadheads, even if you don’t know it yet.

So, what are they? Three blades, one-piece, across a one-inch and one-eighths cutting diameter, that’s about all you need to know for how sturdy they can be.

Those blades are injection molded, so the tip is a complete solid with absolutely zero fixture points where something can break off.

They’re also poised at the perfect cut-on-contact angle to do maximum damage when they do penetrate your target, ensuring a generous blood trail to follow.

The extra heft behind these arrows makes them perfect for piercing hide, powdering bone, and taking your target down for good.

If you’re breaking one of these tips after loosing an arrow, we’d humbly suggest you stop trying to hunt rocks.

If the prospect of a molded arrow tip scares you, don’t worry. These Montec broadheads have three different grain options, so everybody gets to join in on the fun.

For those of you who might be new, the grain is simply the weight of the broadhead that can be expressed in grains per inch (GPI) or grains per pound (GPP).

You have the choice between standard 100 grain or heftier 125-grain Montec broadheads, both of which you can use with different bow types, including even crossbows, as long as you calibrate properly.

Once fired, these broadheads are easy to reuse and sharpen, so this purchase should stick around with you for quite some time.

If these arrows are hammers, then it only makes sense that you need to hit the nail on its head. By that we mean you need to be confident in your aim to use these.

They’re full-bodied and sail through the air but beginners may find a learning curve they need to get over before they can get the most out of these broadheads.

Pros

• Injection-molded broadheads – Sturdy, one-piece broadheads that sport a 1 1/8” cutting diameter for drawing a lot of blood.
• Angled for cutting perfection – Specifically angled to cut through rough hides and thick flesh with ease.
• Available in multiple grains – You can get these in both 100 and 125-grain versions, depending on your preferred weight and bow type.
• Tapered point design – Makes these broadheads much easier to resharpen.

Cons

• Simple yet steep learning curve – A simple but hefty broadhead design that requires an accurate aim to get the most out of them.

2. Slick Trick Magnum Broadheads

There’s a simplicity to the Montec broadheads above that can drive some people away. If that’s you, check out these Slick Trick Magnum broadheads for a good alternative.

These are the ones for you if you want even more blades for even more cutting power.

Sure, they take some assembly, but when that’s done you have a set of highly effective piercing tips that stay put thanks to the secure super steel ferrules that bond them to your arrow shafts.

That piercing power comes from the bone-splitting chisel tips that these broadheads have.

This is where the blades don’t reach the tip, which is instead reserved for its own point that’s designed to put kinetic pressure on bones.

Taking bones out of action is a surefire way to avoid having to trek through the woods looking for blood, remember that.

Attached to the chisel tip are four blades. That’s one more than most fixed-blade broadheads, and they total one-inch and one-eighth in cutting diameter too.

That extra blade will come in handy when you do need to scout for blood, as the wound is now bigger and has more lacerations contributing to blood flow.

Another point in these broadheads’ favor is the fact that it shares a lot with our Montec broadheads at number one.

For example, these Slick Trick broadheads also have both 100-grain and 125-grain purchase options for varied hunters, and that in turn means these can be used in most bow types and also the crossbow.

Pros

• Chisel-tipped point – A very sharp and narrow point is great for breaking bones to incapacitate prey.
• Four blades – Unlike the first two broadheads, these have four blades for maximum cutting power across their 1 1/8” diameter.
• Super steel ferrules – Resists any pressures that could break the broadhead off.
• Multiple grain options – Available in both 100 and 125 for those who need heavier arrows that work in different bow types.

Cons

• May require paper tuning – These arrows are said to fly best when your bow is paper-tuned.

Last update on 2024-11-08 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

3. Wasp Archery Drone Broadheads

Next, we have the Wasp Archery Drone broadheads, a set of trocar-tipped designs that look a lot like the Slick Trick ones we’ve covered above.

These Drone Broadheads are best described as the above Slick Trick models but with just three blades. That’s why it’s just below because it compares well but doesn’t compete due to blade count.

Still, those three blades do their job well. With them, you can get great penetration from the trocar tip that has been used.

This is made from 100% stainless steel and is designed to punch straight through tough hide and even bone. It can tackle animal bone because each tip is machined with a Rockwell rating of 46C.

Like the others, these broadheads are available in hefty 125 grain and a humbler 100 grain. Between these two broadhead weight profiles, you shouldn’t have any problem finding the right fit for your bow and strength.

No matter what bow you put these broadheads in, you can rely on the reduced ferrule surface area to cut down on wind resistance. This allows your shots to fly straight and true.

A notable downside is that you must replace the blades on these broadheads when they get dull or break, adding fragile fixture points into the equation.

Pros

• Stainless steel trocar tip – A form of chisel tip, these points are ideal for piercing rough elk-like hide.
• Hardened to Rockwell 46C – Ensuring that bone breaks too when hits, incapacitating targets to end any chase before it begins.
• Reduced ferrule surface area – Minimizes air resistance so that your shots can fly as straight and accurately as possible.
• 100 or 125-grain broadheads – Can be acquired in both 100 and 125-grain broadhead variants.

Cons

• Replaceable blades – The blades will need replacing after prolonged use.

Last update on 2024-11-08 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

4. Magnus 4 Blade Hornet Broadheads

Our last recommendation for today also has four blades but this time the arrangement is slightly different.

The blades are those of the Magnus 4 Blade Hornet broadheads, which are also arranged to be cut-on-contact so that you can draw more blood from your prey in a shorter amount of time.

This means less stalking and waiting for your prey to fall after you’ve tagged them.

The combination of four blades and the main two being cut-on-contact mean that this broadhead is highly effective at leaving gruesome wounds that, if not patched, will bring down just about any animal while leaving a nice long blood trail for you to follow.

As if that wasn’t enough, the broadheads are durable because each blade is built into the tip.

The weight of the broadhead tip will depend on what you buy.

If you’re using a lighter bow and generally perform better with a lighter weight setup, you’ll want to reach for the 100-grain versions while the 125 versions are reserved for those who need that extra punch behind each shot.

Pros

• Four cut-on-contact blades – These Magnus broadheads don’t just have four blades, its two main ones are cut-on-contact to maximize bloodletting.
• One-piece construction – All four points are machined into the ferrule, securing it all together for enhanced durability.
• Able to be purchased at multiple weights – Choose whether you want standard 100-grain broadheads or heavier 125-grain versions.

Cons

• Noisy – Creates some noise when flying through the air, potentially alerting local wildlife.

Last update on 2024-11-08 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Buyer’s Guide

Hunting the Best Fixed Blade Broadheads

Fixed blade broadheads aren’t made equal, so let’s finish off with a small guide on how to measure the effectiveness of a broadhead without even holding it in your hands.

There are a lot of factors we can look at, so check out the below sections if you’re new to the bowhunting world and want some help deciding what kind of broadheads are right for you.

Blade Count

Blade count can be directly correlated with how much prey bleeds. It’s not a hard and fast rule, of course, and we’ll talk about other factors below.

You need to decide how many blades you want on your broadhead.

Two is a great place for many to start but can hold back seasoned archers, who would rather have a broadhead with three blades instead, which prioritize clout over cutting by creating a triangular tip shape.

Otherwise, four blades seem to be all the rage at the moment as cut-on-contact surfaces become tenable again.

Tip Design

With fixed blade broadheads, there are two main tip designs that you can also see in the above list. The first, cut-on-contact, is perhaps what you’d expect from arrow tips.

These bladed ends are specially designed to slice into prey and agitate the wound, removing more blood from the prey. That has two benefits.

One, it’ll incapacitate quicker and two, you can follow the trail and find it when it does.

The second tip design is different. It still includes several blades and a cutting diameter to induce bleeding, but this time there’s a specialized tip.

Called trocar or chisel tips, these broadheads are cut into very sharp points at their tip.

The logic here is that these trocar tips house more energy behind a smaller surface area, effectively shattering bones when hitting mid to long-distance shots.

Durability and Weight

Possibly the largest draw of fixed blade broadheads, they’re simple in their construction and so more difficult to break.

If you have a special way of damaging your hunting equipment while out on the road, you’ll probably benefit from more durable fixed blade broadheads for all your needs.

As for weight, you’ll find broadheads available in 85, 100, and 125-grain variants. 85 is on the lighter side, perfect for weaker bows and weaker hunters as a result, like the elderly.

100 is about the average while 125 is a heavier tip intended for somebody who can handle the extra weight and leverage that during a hunt to do more damage.

Maintenance

How you maintain your broadheads is important. You can’t expect to reuse your broadheads if they’re highly complicated and require a lot of maintenance. Fortunately for you, fixed blade broadheads are just hunks of metal.

Their level of maintenance will depend on the specific ones you get. If your blade is a one-piece solid arrow tip, then you just need to sharpen it every now and then to keep them, well, sharp.

As long as they’re sharp and undamaged, you can reuse fixed blade broadheads till they do break.

The exception here is detachable blade broadheads. Though technically fixed, this is where you attach the original blades to the broadhead base.

You can sharpen them too but the main idea is that you can replace them when they get too dull and beyond saving.

Price

If you’re saving on cash, it’s just the truth that fixed-blade broadheads are less sophisticated, and so less expensive, than other types.

Between this and their general reusability, fixed blade arrows are the perfect choice for hunters on a budget.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are fixed blade broadheads legal?

Every state has different laws and even different towns can disagree on broadhead legality, so you need to check for your own area.

Legality can depend on size, blade count, whether there are barbs, et cetera.

The standard fixed blade broadhead should be legal most of the time, as should the products we’ve reviewed above.

Are fixed broadheads better than mechanical?

Fixed blade broadheads and mechanical broadheads differ a lot, so ‘better’ is a subjective term here. It depends on what you value in your arrows.

Many who come to pages just like this are looking for reliable broadheads, which fixed blade broadheads excel at over mechanical. 

When deployed successfully, mechanical broadheads can be devastating game-enders for the deer or hog you’re shooting at, and penetrate much deeper due to superior in-air aerodynamics.

How do I sharpen them?

Sharpening your fixed blade broadheads is as easy as finding a sharpening stone. Depending on where you are, that could be hard.

We’re assuming if you’re at somewhere where you own a bow and arrows, and you’re allowed to hunt with them, you can access a sharpening stone.

You can use stones used for sharpening certain tools too. Either way, once you have your stone, mark the blades of your broadhead so you can keep track of which ones you’ve sharpened and not.

Then just press firmly against the stone, ensuring pressure is kept against the arrow.